Lankao fire questioning: Why can a person "can" government "can't"?

A fire that occurred in a private adoption site caused Yuan to severely question the whirlpool of public opinion and local authorities. One by one, the reporter sorted out the four questions that the society had made to Yuan and the three major investigations of local authorities. The powerful “energy” of Yuan contrasted sharply with the “not” of the local authorities. Just as people who are well acquainted with Yuan, it seems that only such a powerful Yuan can fill the vacancies in the relevant departments “doing nothing”.

Yuan's powerful "energy"

A fire that took away the lives of seven children finally forced Yuan to kneel down and lay in the hospital.

In the early morning of January 6, she was sent to rescue her family and sent her infusion until 4 am due to her faintness caused by excessive heartburn. According to his son-in-law, Guo Haiyang, after experiencing this incident, Yuan’s powerful spirit was close to collapse and her heart attack recurred. She also suffered from hypertension and diabetes.

For a long time, the figure of a fat woman was not only recognized as a “good man” by the local people, but also was affixed with a “can of people” label. This tag, accompanied by a series of questions and disputes related to it, has also added a lot of shadow to its "good man" image.

The "Legal Daily" reporter scrutinized that the most serious questions about Yuan were concentrated on the following points, namely "using child custodial adoptions", "selling children", "using reputation to solicit projects", "bringing children to the government to make trouble" , to the government to provide conditions "and so on.

Cheat protection, Lankao County government has clarified that it is indeed for the family of Yuan to handle 20 rural minimum guarantees, and Yuan can earn a minimum guarantee of 1,740 yuan a month.

"Resell children" said, originated in 2010, the local volunteer organization reported that Yuan Yuan was very powerful, saying that it sold some of its heart and rabbit cleft lip repair operations successfully, and sold it to others for profit. “In such a simple environment, how can children grow up? Why should the civil affairs department not care for the children?

In an interview with the media, Yuan admitted that he would “send” some children who had recovered to need children. Prior to this, she also publicly stated that she really wanted to have “support payments” and “milk powder money.”

Regarding the use of fame to solicit projects, his mother Zhang Suye confirmed to reporters that there are indeed many people who come to the door to look for her and help the project. “Because she is good.” However, Yuan has severely openly disclosed this: “There are three roads in the county that I have led and repaired. The businessman family also believes me. Others want 5,000 yuan. I only need 3,000 yuan to earn some money to support the children.”

“Yuan has no shortage of money, engages in real estate, takes highways, and collects debts for the people...she has done all these activities.” Before that, some media quoted the staff of the government department of Lankao County as saying that Yuan also severely borrowed and “reached out”. When the government was given conditions, she took a group of handicapped children to the office. She even let her children pee in the office. She was so frightened that everyone feared her.

When a journalist of the Legal Daily reported that during his visit in Lankao, this statement was widely spread. Several public officials confirmed to reporters that Yuan had severely brought the child to the government to make trouble and had money, “but the government did not give it to the end.” .

These doubts are seen by Guo Haiyang, Yuan’s powerful son-in-law: “A few thousand dollars a month’s subsistence allowance is enough for several children to spend? Not to take away some children, how to feed other children? Say to use children and the government. If you mention the conditions, can you mention the conditions? You see she can't eat, she can't wear it, and the money is saved for the child.”

For these widely questioned measures, Yuan has also repeatedly expressed his own hardships: "Relying on a stall can not support so many children."

“I think from another angle, if the mother did not retain these children over the years, did you say that it was a good example now? Was it that they were dead at that time?” Guo Guoyang was quite positive about Yuan’s behavior, he thought, replacing No one else can do this "untold."

In a recent interview with the media, Yuan severely said: "I have said that I have been cheating on the low-risk cheating. I said that if you have to support you better than I, I will give you my children."

This confidence is not without credentials. In the past few days, a reporter from the “Legal Daily” survey in Lankao found that what Yuan Yuan has done for children is not something that most people can do.

The Lankao County official stated that in addition to the subsistence allowances for 20 children, the relevant departments also applied for household registration procedures for some of the adopted persons, and many of these practices did not comply with the relevant regulations. According to a civilian police officer of the Lankao County Public Security Bureau, of the children who were severely adopted by Yuan, the number of people who had applied for a residence accounted for more than 30 people. "This is very difficult to do. In the first two years, because of problems, we have very strict management of the household registration. It is enough to account for so many abandoned children.

On the issue of children's admission, Yuan has also demonstrated his ability to handle more than ordinary people. Taking Dongjie Primary School as an example, a reporter from Legal Daily reported that in 2007, Yuan severely prevented four children from attending the school for free, and the leader of Chengguan Town “finished a sliver” and successfully entered the school.

The relevant department's "can't"

At 4 pm on January 7th, after sitting down in front of reporters, Feng Jie, chief of the social rescue unit of Lankao County Civil Affairs Bureau, said: “There are indeed some omissions in our work.”

A similar statement was made by Wu Changsheng, the deputy county governor of Lankao County, two days ago. He said: “In the case of the powerful adoption and abandonment of infants by Yuan, the civil affairs departments do have weak supervision, and they are interested in being more direct than management and have irresponsible responsibilities.”

As of press time, the official of Lankao County has not reported the results of the accident investigation, and the cause of the fire and its responsibility have not been clearly defined. The public opinion chose to stand on the side of supporting Yuan’s fierceness. No matter what the responsibility she should bear in accordance with the law, her “acts” in adopting abandonment of abandoned infants are frequently used in the matter with the local Civil Affairs Bureau. Do not compare ".

"Legal Daily" reporter combed lyrical discovery, the Lankao County Civil Affairs Bureau's "non-action" accusations, mainly in three areas: Why not adopt an abandoned baby? Why not support and manage Yuan Yuan? Why not take responsibility for accidents?

Why don't you adopt an abandoned baby?

Feng Jie began to work in the social rescue unit of Lankao County Civil Affairs Bureau in 2007. This office with four staff members, before 2011, was the only job in charge of abandoned baby care. Beginning in 2011, according to the “Opinions of the General Office of the State Council on Strengthening Orphan Safeguard Work,” the department also began to take charge of this task.

Feng Jie told the "Legal Daily" reporter that the adoption of abandonment of infants generally takes such a process: "After picking up abandoned babies, someone must first report the case to the police station and send it from the police station to the Civil Affairs Bureau. The Civil Affairs Bureau will issue an abandoned baby identity. Proof, sent to Kaifeng City Welfare Institute."

Yuan Hai’s son-in-law Guo Hai revealed to the Legal Daily reporter that in Lankao, some children were abandoned in hospitals and health centers. The doctors would call Yuan to pick them up; they would often open up in the morning and open their doors.

Why did the abandoned baby not be sent to the Civil Affairs Bureau and sent to Yuan Jiajia? Feng Jie said in an interview with the media earlier that the real reason why Yuan’s severe adoption of abandoned babies was increasingly uncontrollable was that Lankao did not have a welfare home. Why does Lankao not build its own orphanage? Feng Jie's answer is very necessary, but it is still not listed in the priority plan for county development.

Lankao County official stated that after several efforts, the civil affairs department had taken more than 10 young children and the rest of the older people followed Yuan’s life. Wang Yongxi, head of the Kaifeng Social Welfare Institute, also said publicly: “In my 5 years as president, I have convinced Yuan to send children to welfare institutions 10 times and invited Yuan to the welfare institutions several times. After the visit, Yuan said that the condition of the orphanage was good and he promised to send the child, but he did not believe it when he returned home.”

The other argument given by Guo Haiyang was: “We also sent it to the Kaifeng Welfare Institute. But when they arrived, they asked us to go through the formalities. Where did the child come? To prove it, but there was no way to do it. I don't know where the abandoned baby is. There are some public security bureaus that have issued certificates for you, but some will not be opened to you."

Why not support or not manage

Wu Changsheng stated that according to relevant laws and regulations, Yuan severely does not have the conditions for adoption, but considering that his behavior is an action that focuses on people's livelihood and cares for vulnerable groups. “In this case, we acquiesced to this kind of behavior.”

Since the civil affairs department of Lankao County has acquiesced in the private adoption of Yuan, does it not only help the 20 children to apply for minimum living guarantee and household registration, but has they conducted other management and support?

The Ministry of Civil Affairs issued the "Notice on Initiatives to Strengthen the Management of Orphaned Children and Privately-owned Organizations" on the 6th and asked the local civil affairs departments to deeply learn the lesson of the "1. 4" fire incident in Lankao, Henan Province, and take the initiative to take care of the orphans of individuals and private organizations. Management work.

It is proposed that, for those who already have the conditions for raising children, and if they insist on parenting orphans, the civil affairs department must sign a joint agreement with them to clarify the responsibilities and include the supervision of the civil affairs department. This provides a healthy existence for private adoptions such as Yuan.

And this possibility is not only emerged afterwards. The "Legal Daily" reporter learned that after the "Opinions of the General Office of the State Council on Strengthening Orphan Safeguard Work" was issued at the end of 2010, in May 2011, Henan Province also issued the "General Office of the Henan Provincial Government to Strengthen Orphan Safeguard Work." "Opinions", Henan Provincial Civil Affairs Department subsequently issued a document requesting the strengthening of orphans to guide parenting.

The Henan Provincial Department of Civil Affairs requires that the civil affairs department of the county-level people’s government should sign a guiding parenting agreement with the guardians of scattered orphans or through the Child Welfare Guidance Center and social diaspora orphan’s guardians to clarify the guardian’s guardianship and support obligations and collect and use guardians’ orphans. Basic living expenses and raising the quality of raising orphans raise requirements;

The issuance of this series of documents means that, in addition to the social diaspora orphans being included in the management, the support for orphaned children should be strengthened. Relevant documents stipulate that the standard of low-standard care for orphans in Henan Province is: Social diaspora orphans should be no less than 600 yuan per person per month, and institutional orphans should not be less than 1,000 yuan per person per month.

The local public welfare subsidy for orphans announced by the Lankao County Bureau of Civil Affairs is only 350 yuan. Feng Jie explained that this is because the level of economic development in different regions is different.

Even with these 350 yuan, the children who were severely adopted by Yuan did not enjoy it. According to statistics released by the Civil Affairs Bureau of Lankao County, there are 595 orphans and disabled children identified in the county, including 4 disabled orphans. Of these orphans, 472 were raised by grandparents and 123 were raised by other relatives. However, "according to the relevant regulations of the Provincial Civil Affairs Department, the abandoned babies that were taken up by Yuan Juqiang and others are not included in the above statistics."

"This refers to orphans, or both parents died, or other reasons, the family, relatives care, and abandoned baby is different. At present, the country has not provided for this piece of abandoned baby." Feng Jie explained to reporters.

However, the "Legal Daily" reporter found a "Notice of the Department of Civil Affairs of Henan Province on Checking and Registering the Orphan's Identity." This notice clearly stipulates "conditions for the determination of orphans", including the "cannot find out the abandoned parents of their parents." And minors under the age of 18". According to the regulations, at least children who have already registered for household registration can "according to the relevant provisions of the "Registration Procedures for the Adoption of Children by Chinese Citizens"."

However, the powerful children of Yuan have never been able to obtain the status of an “orphan” and have never enjoyed a subsistence allowance of at least 350 yuan per month as required.

Why not take responsibility

Wu Changsheng told reporters that from the legal point of view, according to the adoption regulations introduced in 1991 and revised in 1998, adoption of abandoned babies and children requires four conditions: First, no children, and second, ability to support children. Is not suffering from medical conditions that should not adopt a child's disease, fourth is the age of 30 years old, and must be registered at the civil affairs department above the county level.

Wu Changsheng said that Yuan Li, born in 1966, had two men and a woman, and all of them had already married and lived independently. From a legal point of view, Yuan is not completely qualified for adoption.

When Yang Peimin, the director of Lankao County Civil Affairs Bureau, was interviewed by the media, his expression was even more direct: “According to the provisions of the adoption law, Yuan does not qualify for adoption, has no ability to adopt an abandoned baby, and has no relevant procedures, and is illegally adopted. ”

"Illegal Adoption" came out, which led to questioning. After accepting media interviews, Li Meibiao, deputy secretary of the Party Committee of the Lancao County Civil Affairs Bureau, said in a media interview that the previous argument against Yuan’s “unlawful adoption” was not accurate enough and should be called “private adoption”.

However, Guo Guohai did not agree even if it was privately adopted. "Relevant also admitted that they acquiesced to my mother's behavior. As an inaction department, to criticize a person's love move, this matter was originally yours. Now people give you control, and after things happen, you And come out and accuse others, saying that you can't control this thing, and you don't blush when you blush?"

As of the press release, none of the officials in Lankao County have assumed responsibility for official negligence.

Next post:Guangdong woman returned to her parents frozen halo into the police car to warm the roadside
Previous post: Men's subway hitting the eardrum after pushing the girl complained